APHA hits back at Grattan Institute

Latest News

The Australian Private Hospitals Association has criticised the Grattan Institute’s health plan director Stephen Duckett for getting "basic facts wrong about private hospital efficiency and costs".

Mr Duckett claimed during an ABC Radio interview that private hospital costs were rising ‘very rapidly’ and private hospital length of stay is longer than in public hospitals.

However, according to the APHA, "The facts are clear, data from the independent Australian Institute of Health and Welfare shows private hospital length of stay was 2.2 days in 2017-2018 compared to 3.0 days in public hospitals.

"Some of this difference is due to private hospitals performing two thirds of all same day admissions, but when these are excluded from both sectors, the average length of stay in private hospitals is 5.2 days, still lower than the public average of 5.4 days."

APHA CEO Michael Roff said Mr Duckett’s assertion that private hospital costs are rising and pushing up premiums was not true.

“Since 2016, the average cost per episode of private hospital services has increased at about the same rate as inflation. This is despite the fact patients treated by private hospitals are older and have more complex conditions than ever before,” said Mr Roff said.

“You can’t participate in this debate if you can’t get your basic facts right. Despite this, Mr Duckett has again charged in, laying the blame for unaffordable premiums at the feet of private hospitals and conveniently ignoring the $1.5 billion in private health insurance benefits gouged by public hospitals every year, driving up premiums and extending public waiting lists,” he said.